how to trade binary options and win as a business
binary option guide websites
hand signal trading floor
digital vs binary option live trading room
stock market crash 2016
lazy trader binary options trading top 10
how to start a home based business for dummies
learn how to use penny stocks
watch binary options trading signals copy a live trader in action
history of the amsterdam stock exchange
singapore binary options regulati
online stock broker philippines 2015
binary options in the usa reddit
fantasy football trading draft picks strategy
brief summary of the stock market crash of 1929
baking business from home ontario
how to predict binary option correctly legal
binary options di hamish raw 60 seconds
binary option forecasting software autopilot
is binary option legal in malaysia brokers uk
how do binary option brokers work box
quicken home business 2015 license
binary options trading simulator or penny stocks
best binary options broker for beginners australia
india stock exchange companies list
is how to trade forex binary options successfully legal in australia
ea for registered binary option brokers
delta of a binary option trading info
binary option straddle strategy youtube news
how is the stock market going to do tomorrow
top 3 trading binary options with franco brokers
course for stock trading
fully automated binary option software strategies
how to win in binary option news martingale strategy
binary option scalper free 100
good futures trading strategies
forex binary option system omni11 reviews xp
binary options broker with demo account trading
australian stock exchange market capitalisation
home business internet service
is binary options signal providers a scam
shenzhen stock exchange component index
b 99 binary options
binary options system audio income
binary option strategies 4 management franco
binary option fraud strategies g
good price binary options trading halal with paypal sale
malaysia stock market broker
us stock market rates
you too can trade binary options in singapore
xforex top regulated binary option broker
thread video on trading binary strangles on nadex during the news
securities and exchange commission binary option 60 sec strategy
currency forex trading
24 bulls how to hedge in binary options
is home business finder legit
income from binary option glossary
binary options brokers accept moneybookers
binary options bullet forum in sa
stock broker exams
what time does the sydney stock exchange open
top futures trading books
trade binary options bonus 300
trusted binary options brokers millionaires
commodity futures trading margins
online trading terminal india
why binary option is better than forex system 81
reputable us binary options brokers testimonials
index binary options made simple
mr is binary options legal in uk
idbi online trading demo
binary option strategies used for health care reform no minimum deposit
become a successful binary option trader watchdog
etrade how to trade options
binary option company investing
stock market analysis for 2015
stock trading options united states
part time job chicago craigslist binary option system jacket
gft make money binary option
exploit the jpy binary options loophole
2 hour real time graphics binary options
a forex trading system based on a genetic algorithm pdf
how to use binary options trading signa
binary options trading bad bonuses
does scottrade do binary option kaskus
best binary option trading platform vic review
asian stock markets latest
1 hour binary options trading robots
stock market update yahoo
us binary options trading websites i
option trading square off
future and options trading
binary options strategies revealed buddy 2 0 mt4
stock exchange thailand today
have any penny stocks made it big
how to make extra money online in canada
stock market crash forum
live binary option trading minimum deposit
live stock market birmingham
stock exchange of japan
stock market crash 1929 results
binary options leading indicators mt4 plugin
well known companies that are penny stocks
how to consistently make money in the stock market
stock market plunges after election
want to start business from home in mumbai
binary options strategies journal physical education winning formula
who is the director general of the nigerian stock exchange
free online software for stock market
what is a binary option company free 100
home based business and homeowners insurance
the binary options insider kishore
i love binary options us
binary option risk reward ratio or forex
options trading pro
free binary options deposit live signals
5 decimal binary options industry
analog vs binary controls review nadex forex options
the stock market crash 1920
invest in binary options system zarzadzania jakoscia
binary options forex warrior money management
explain which is the best binary options broker
definition of stock market downturn
bangladesh stock market collapse
download binary clock
nifty option trading basics
online binary options trading strategies za
buying and selling penny stocks online
metatrader ea price of binary options
best company to trade binary options 100 strategy
london stock market overview
best binary option brokers 2015 60s
australian regulated binary option strategies i
stock market futures tomorrow
software for nifty option trading
stock market forecast for december 2015
4xp binary options trading wikipedia review
go green home based business
binary options money management system deposit
signals for binary option system 0ne
binary option vs betting real
trade binary options australia uk broker
network marketing binary compensation plan
stock market closed storm
ttulo trade binary options h aqui algum expert
trade binary option safely valuation
successful binary trading
1 binary option trading rules broker
1 minute binary options system 2015
black lion trading company online
how to trade the news in binary option nedir
best binary options software kishore
stock market tips review
binary option trading platforms ladder
binary trading guide for beginners and semiadvanced traders
binary option ladder vic review
make money online legit and free 2015
nigerian stock market news today
binary option fraud 2015 auto
canadian online stock trading comparison
big companies that are now penny stocks
stock market averages update
tricks of zoom to success trading binary options from beginner pro
south korea stock exchange website
binary options signals 90 accuracy articles
binary option 1 minute indicator commodities
do i need a business license to work from home
best trading strategies for beginners
binary option live trading room
binary options software revie
binary options forex peace army fraud
binary option methods really work 24h
how does a binary option broker make money coach
todays stock exchange market
investment options in india for tax saving
best binary option auto trader system 75
trading binary options on leumi bank
understanding the stock market crash
silk road an online blackmarket trading site
tradesmarter binary options methods have been
60 second binary options strategy new system delivers quick profits
what company is commonly referred to with the symbol t for the stock exchange
london stock exchange market cap
index binary options platinum signals
binary trading 5 minute bars
professional binary options traders us regulation
the best binary options site 2015
binary option stock signal matlab
Home Discussion Papers Africa Watch Solving Somalia: Beyond a military approach
Solving Somalia: Beyond a military approach
Written by Katharine Dennys (1) Monday, 16 April 2012 08:10

Somalia is currently experiencing its worst humanitarian crisis for decades, with more than 325,000 children suffering from acute malnutrition, and 31% of the total population estimated to be in crisis.(2) The recent ‘London Conference on Somalia’, held on 23 February 2012, proposed a new framework to approach the continuing crisis in Somalia, its internal stability and the terrorist threat it poses beyond its borders. The proposal set out at the Conference has, however, come under criticism for relying too heavily on a military approach whilst side-lining inclusive humanitarian approaches which aim to solve the root causes of conflict. This CAI paper argues that despite many obstacles facing the humanitarian effort, there do still exist opportunities for an inclusive approach that deserves greater attention from the international community. It argues that ignoring this approach through a reliance on externally led security measures will serve to further exacerbate tensions and encourage extremist violence within Somali borders.

The Conference receives criticism

Following the discussions which took place on 23 February 2012, United Kingdom (UK) Prime Minister, David Cameron, proposed a “seven point plan” for Somalia, stating that measures to deal with security issues, piracy, terrorism, humanitarian assistance, local stability, political process and international coordination had been agreed on.(3)

Although the discussion of humanitarian issues was high on the Conference’s agenda, these were arguably side-lined on the day by security concerns surrounding terrorism and piracy. The fact that humanitarian issues were discussed in a separate side meeting co-chaired by the United Nations (UN) and the United Arab Emirates highlights its lack of centrality in the process.

The London Conference backed a UN Security Council resolution proposing to increase the number of African Union (AU) troops operating within Somalia by 5,000, to over 17,000 troops.(4) The resolution also proposed to give the AU mission extra funding for extending its mandate. This highlights the hard-line stance taken during the Conference towards al-Shabaab militants operating within and outside of Somalia. This was reflected in United States Secretary of State, Hilary Clinton’s views when she stated that the world “must keep al-Shabaab on the run,” and that there was no possibility of negotiation with members of al-Shabaab.(5)

The Conference also saw a focus on piracy, which has been described as an “affront on the rule of international law.”(6) The Conference proposed tougher laws in order to try and imprison pirates due to the threat the piracy business poses to international trade and insurance industries. It is this focus on international security concerns that has resulted in the conference receiving criticism for defending foreign interest as opposed to the interests of Somali people, and pursuing a policy which neglects the importance of a humanitarian approach.

Emergence of ‘failed state’ rhetoric

The importance of the international community working alongside AU troops in order to fight the threat posed by al-Shabaab militants was central in the London discussions surrounding Somalia’s future. It was highlighted by Cameron’s statement that “the connection between military action to put a huge pressure on Shabaab… and the political process, are two sides of the same coin.”(7) This focus on a military response has been criticised by non-governmental organisations (NGOs) as representing an external solution which fails to include the voice of the people. Speaking after the Conference, Barbara Stocking from Oxfam International stated in a press release that ‘What we’ve seen once again were external solutions that haven’t worked, aren’t working and will not work.”(8)

The problem with the military approach is that it focuses too heavily on ‘quick-fix’ military approaches aimed at neutralising immediate threats. In this context, humanitarian approaches built on a more long-term time-scale have taken a “back-seat” to “short-sighted” policies driven by a counter-terrorism agenda.(9) This has been a result of a “noticeable policy shift” in 2008, when the United States (US) listed al-Shabaab as a terrorist organisation under US law, resulting in a decrease in aid to Somalia.(10)

The militaristic approach stems from the idea that Somalia is a ‘failed state’ due to its lack of centralised governance, widespread terrorism and insecurity. A pre-occupation with this ‘failed state’ rhetoric was noted in the run up to the Conference, as UK Foreign Secretary, William Hague, was frequently reported to have used the phrase “Somalia is the world’s worst failed state” in his communications.(11) This mind-set amongst politicians explains the emphasis on solutions aiming to neutralise the threat posed to external actors rather than supporting the country from within, as it sees inclusive peace initiatives as unworkable within Somalia’s volatile security situation.

Limitations of a military approach

There are currently extreme challenges to the aid effort within Somalia, as aid agencies are limited by both Transitional Federal Government (TFG) imposed restrictions and armed opposition groups. The TFG has limited the movement of foreign aid workers outside of TFG controlled areas which led to the arrest, in September 2011, of 10 aid workers distributing aid in the Lower Shabelle region.(12) Furthermore, armed militias have also been known to impose taxes which put aid workers in a difficult position due to allegations of ‘taking sides’, and resulting in time consuming negotiations.(13) Due to this persistent insecurity and lack of governance systems, it is extremely difficult to monitor the movements of aid on the ground.

Within this context the military approach may seem the most attractive option to improve security both regionally and for Somali citizens. However, the military approach proposed in the Conference may serve to further exacerbate conflict and hinder aid getting to the right places.

Since the beginning of 2012, aid workers in Somalia have reported a deteriorating humanitarian situation as a result of expanded military operations, as thousands of civilians have been forced to flee to safety.(14) According to Oxfam, particular areas in which military operations are hindering aid efforts include: the northern Hiraan region, where continued fighting is blocking a key entry point for aid supplies, the Gedo region which has seen an upsurge in airstrikes, renewed fighting and hostage taking, and Lower Juba, where fighting and airstrikes have forced residents to flee towns.(15)

Given this information, it can, therefore, be asserted that proposed plans to run military operations alongside a humanitarian effort will ultimately fail as the humanitarian effort cannot be effective within a war zone. This is due not only to the restrictions placed on humanitarian efforts by military activities. “The Somali case shows that military intervention in Somalia is hugely unpopular, and can act as a catalyst to whip up Somali nationalism to unite Somali groups that had, hitherto, been sworn enemies.”(16) Military operations may also be ineffective due to the fact that “coercive efforts to stabilise Somalia, including forcible disarmament, undermine the balance of power between clans and communities and will always be met with resistance.”(17)

An alternative approach: Giving Somalia back its voice

The London Conference has received criticism for lacking specific plans for post-conflict stabilisation, and for not offering a long-term solution for sustainable development. NGO’s have highlighted the importance of an “inclusive, Somali-led peace process,” proposing a shift in approach which includes the use of local peace initiatives and civil society.(18)  

On 22 February 2012, Oxfam published a paper which sets out a “new agenda” for creating long-term peace and stability in Somalia.(19) One main point made in the report is the importance of working internally with influential local actors within Somalia such as elders, religious leaders and members of the Somali business community in order to promote humanitarian access. These groups, which form an integral part of Somali society, are too often overlooked in the quest for regional security and counter-terrorism initiatives.

A study conducted by the Centre of Research and Dialogue (CRD) found that since the collapse of the Somali Government in 1991 there have been more than 90 local peace initiatives in south central Somalia which have used traditional conflict mediation practices under the guidance of clan elders, Islamic scholars and other key stakeholders.(20) The CRD report states that the majority of these peace initiatives are “social,” in that they address violence as a consequence of the social structure; addressing conflicts over shared land, pastoral resources or clan-related revenge killings.(21)

Oker argues that international efforts have “compounded” the problem of insecurity within Somalia due to their reliance on armed faction leaders as their primary interlocutors in Somalia.(22) Furthermore, Brickhill argues that states that are externally imposed are viewed with “suspicion and alarm,” whereas locally owned initiatives based on “painstaking consultation, negotiation and confidence-building” have achieved “tangible and enduring” success.(23)

Concluding remarks

The Islamic extremism which is creating the current chaos and insecurity within Somalia, and which further threatens international security beyond its borders, is rooted within the social fabric of the nation. External state-led approaches to solving Somalia’s security crisis, therefore, cannot succeed within this context. If the international community were to approach Somali insecurity from a grass-roots level, supporting local peace-building initiatives as opposed to an external military approach, it could catch endemic conflict at its roots. As this paper has shown, there are certain avenues that can be exploited to promote inclusive sustainable development which go beyond externally-led solutions. Although Somali civil society has been greatly damaged due to 20 years of civil war, and the process of negotiation and consensus-building at a grass roots level is slow and time consuming, civil society should not be overlooked by the international community in favour of ‘quick-fix’ counter-terrorism initiatives. The International community needs to look beyond its own national interests and strengthen Somalia from within; only then will regional stability and sustainable growth be achievable.

NOTES:

(1) Contact Katharine Dennys through Consultancy Africa Intelligence's Africa Watch Unit ( This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it ).
(2) ‘A Shift in Focus: Putting the interests of Somali people first’, Oxfam briefing note, 22 February 2012, http://www.oxfam.org.
(3) ‘PM sets out 7-point plan of Somalia’, Politics Home, 23 February 2012, http://www.politicshome.com.
(4) ‘London Conference Backs Somalia Terror Fight’, BBC, 23 February 2012, http://www.bbc.co.uk.
(5) Ibid.
(6) Foreign and Commonwealth Office of the United Kingdom website, http://www.fco.gov.uk.
(7) ‘London Conference Backs Somalia Terror Fight’, BBC, 23 February 2012, http://www.bbc.co.uk.
(8) ‘Oxfam’s reaction to the London Somalia Conference’, Oxfam, 23 February 2012, http://www.oxfam.org.uk.
(9) ‘A Shift in Focus: Putting the interests of Somali people first’, Oxfam briefing note, 22 February 2012, http://www.oxfam.org.
(10) Ibid.
(11) Walls, M., ‘International engagement in Somalia: lessons from Somaliland?’, UCL, 29 February 2012, http://blogs.ucl.ac.uk.
(12) ‘A Shift in Focus: Putting the interests of Somali people first’, Oxfam briefing note, 22 February 2012, http://www.oxfam.org.
(13) Ibid.
(14) Ibid.
(15) Ibid.
(16) Sazawal, S., ‘UK Somalia Conference weak on humanitarian focus, NGOs host own meetings’, Charity and Security Network, 5 March 2012, http://www.charityandsecurity.org.
(17) Bryden, M. and Brickhill, J., 2010. Disarming Somalia: Lessons in stabilisation from a collapsed state. Conflict, Security and Development, 10(2), pp. 239-262.
(18) Bauwens, D., ‘NGOs Urge "Solution from Within" for Somalia’, IPS, 25 February 2012, http://ipsnews.net.
(19) ‘A Shift in Focus: Putting the interests of Somali people first’, Oxfam briefing note, 22 February 2012, http://www.oxfam.org.
(20) Ali Amber, I., 2010. Community peace processes in south central Somalia, Accord, 21, pp. 52-55. 
(21) Ibid.
(22) Ibid.
(23) Bryden, M. and Brickhil,l J., 2010. Disarming Somalia: Lessons in stabilisation from a collapsed state, Conflict, Security and Development, 10(2), pp. 239-262.

 

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Plaxo

Banner
Banner
Banner
Banner